T. Willoughby et al., ISOLATING VARIABLES THAT IMPACT ON OR DETRACT FROM THE EFFECTIVENESS OF ELABORATION STRATEGIES, Journal of educational psychology, 86(2), 1994, pp. 279-289
The role of prior knowledge in elaboration strategies was examined in
3 experiments. University students were presented with material that a
ccessed either a highly developed or a less developed knowledge base a
nd instructed to answer ''why'' questions (elaborative interrogation),
create interactive images (imagery). create interactive images using
keywords (keyword), or read the information aloud (repetition). Across
all 3 experiments. elaborative interrogation was most effective when
learners were able to draw on a rich knowledge base. However, when the
knowledge base was low, imagery-based strategies were more potent tha
n elaborative interrogation. These results suggest that creating menta
l images encourages the processing of both relations and distinctions
to a greater extent than elaborative interrogation when the learners'
background knowledge is limited.