Pd. Warriss et al., RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN SUBJECTIVE AND OBJECTIVE ASSESSMENTS OF STRESS AT SLAUGHTER AND MEAT QUALITY IN PIGS, Meat science, 38(2), 1994, pp. 329-340
A study was carried out to relate subjective and objective measures Of
stress al slaughter and meat quality in pigs. Thirteen slaughter plan
ts were visited. The systems used for handling the pigs pre-slaughter
and the levels of stress experienced by the animals were subjectively
assessed. The sound level immediately before stunning was also measure
d. Generally, systems that were rated as being most stressful also pro
duced higher levels of sound, probably because of the vocalisations of
the pigs. As the size of plant increased, there was a tendency for th
e level of stress, and the recorded sound level, to increase. This app
eared to be because larger plants operated faster and were more likely
to use restraining conveyors supplied by races to handle the animals
before stunning. The restraint associated with these seems stressful t
o pigs. Five plants were selected for further study. Two had been asse
ssed as having handling systems that produced a low level of stress in
the pigs, one as having a system producing a mediwn level, and two as
having poor systems producing high levels of stress. Blood samples we
re collected al exsanguination, and meat quality was assessed. As the
level of subjectively assessed stress experienced by the pigs increase
d, so did the average blood levels of lactate and creatine phosphokina
se (CPK). There was also a progressive increase in the potential incid
ence of pale, soft, exudative (PSE) and dark, firm, dry (DFD) meat in
the plants using more stressful handling systems. Additionally, there
were positive relationships between sound level and lactate and CPK, a
nd sound level and indices of poorer meat quality. Cortisol concentrat
ions were not different in pigs killed in the different systems and pr
obably reflect events earlier in the handling process, such as in tran
sport and lairage, rather than the stress experienced immediately befo
re stunning. The overall conclusion was that subjective assessments of
the stress suffered by pigs correlate well with objective measures an
d that higher stress levels are associated with poorer meat quality.