S. Messick, THE MATTER OF STYLE - MANIFESTATIONS OF PERSONALITY IN COGNITION, LEARNING, AND TEACHING, Educational psychologist, 29(3), 1994, pp. 121-136
The historical roots of cognitive styles are traced in differential ps
ychology, psychoanalytic ego psychology, Gestalt, and cognitive-develo
pmental psychology to illuminate the varied theoretical issues that en
ergize (and fragment) style research. Optimal measurement of cognitive
styles as information-processing regularities and as intraindividual
contrasts of abilities or other attributes is discussed in terms of bo
th typical performance and contrasted performance on measures of oppos
ing ends of bipolar style dimensions, with special emphasis on the con
trasted measurement of field independence versus field dependence. The
role of styles as both performance variables and competence variables
in learning and teaching is examined, as are various critiques of sty
le research that appear to be excessively polarized in either supporti
ng or undercutting styles as meaningful constructs. This polarization
appears to reflect different stances not just with respect to scientif
ic evidence but also with respect to ideology. Concluding remarks broa
ch the issue of how styles are organized, not just within an informati
on-processing framework but within the structure of personality.