In this article, we briefly sketch out the four strands of our program
of research: the nature of history classes; historical reasoning and
thinking in discourse and writing; other dimensions of history; and th
e thinking, reasoning, and discussion of both students and historians.
We then focus on one particular aspect: What is history? We discuss t
he definitions of history offered by published historians, two high sc
hool history teachers, and practicing historians. By contrasting the c
ore elements of what constitutes history for the teachers and the prac
ticing historians, we explicate the similarities and differences that
inform their respective practices. We offer a definition of history th
at synthesizes the two groups; one primarily concerned with teaching t
he subject and the other primarily concerned with the production of it
.