The GR (total tissue thickness at the twelfth rib, 110 mm from the mid
line) was measured with the AUS-MEAT sheep probe (ASP) on lamb carcass
es at chain speed by an abattoir operator in two experiments, both at
the same abattoir. In both experiments, GR was also measured on the ca
rcass by an independent operator using a GR knife. For experiment 1, a
total of 779 lamb carcasses were measured over four occasions and for
experiment 2 data on 607 lamb carcasses were obtained on two occasion
s, twelve months after experiment 1. In both experiments, one operator
measured the manual GR and a different operator used the ASP. A new v
ersion of the ASP was used in the second experiment. In only 30% of ca
ses in experiment 1 did the operator probe at the correct rib, and in
the majority of cases the thirteenth rib was used as the probing site.
In only a small percentage of cases (2%) was the operator more than o
ne rib away from the twelfth rib. In 67% of the cases for experiment 1
, the operator probed at the correct site with respect to distance fro
m the midline. Models were developed to describe the relationship betw
een the manual and ASP GR measurements. In experiment 2, the amount of
variation in manual GR explained by ASP measurements was greater than
that in experiment 1 (R2 = 0.80 compared with 0.72), and the accuracy
of the estimates was significantly increased (+/- 1.54 mm compared wi
th 2.31 mm). The better over-all performance of the ASP in the second
experiment was indicated by the fact that for 90% of the sample the AS
P measurements were within +/-2 mm of the manual GR measurements where
as, for experiment 1, the level was less than 70%. Measurement time (d
ay), which could be described as an operator 'effect', was identified
as an important factor influencing the accuracy of GR estimates but lo
cation of the probed site with respect to the GR site was not found im
portant. The significance of operator training and monitoring is discu
ssed on the basis of the results, as are the implications of the findi
ngs for objective purchasing systems.