Pp. Ketaren et al., PHOSPHORUS STUDIES IN PIGS .2. ASSESSING PHOSPHORUS AVAILABILITY FOR PIGS AND RATS, British Journal of Nutrition, 70(1), 1993, pp. 269-288
Experiments were conducted with pigs and rats to determine the availab
ility of P in feeds. Initially, the availabitity of P in a soya-bean m
eal and field peas (Pisum sativum cultivar Early Dun) was assessed usi
ng a slope-ratio assay for grower pigs. Three different levels of eith
er monosodium phosphate (MSP), soya-bean meal or field peas were added
to a basal sucrose-soya-bean meal diet (2.5 g/kg P) to give three lev
els of P (3.0, 3.5 and 4 g/kg) for each source. The diets were offered
for 35 d at three times maintenance energy requirements to female pig
s initially weighing 20 kg live weight. Several bone variables and the
ash and P concentration and retention levels in the empty body were u
sed as criteria of availability. The responses to MSP were linear for
all variables. However, responses to P in the test proteins, particula
rly soya-bean meal, were mostly non-linear, except for ash and P conce
ntrations and retentions in the empty body. The estimates of P availab
ility in the soya-bean meal and in the field peas were dependent on th
e criteria used to assess availability. Using bone variables as the cr
iterion, the availabilities of P in soya-bean meal and field peas were
approximately 0.17 and 0-38 respectively. Using ash or P concentratio
ns or retentions in the empty body as the response criterion, the avai
labilities of P in soya-bean meal and field peas were 0.61 and 0.38 re
spectively. The mean retention values for P from MSP, soya-bean meal a
nd field peas were 0-74, 0-33 and 0.21 respectively. Experiments were
then conducted to define the conditions necessary for a slope-ratio as
say for P availability with growing rats to determine if they could be
used as a model to assess P availability for pigs. These experiments
examined level of P in the diet, the effect of Ca: P ratio and criteri
a for assessing response (growth rate, feed intake, feed conversion ra
tio, bone ash and bone bending moment). The results indicated that a s
uitable range of dietary P for a slope-ratio assay in rats was 1.8-3.5
g/kg, with Ca: P ratio of between 1.3 and 6.2, and that ash content o
r bone bending moment of the femur bone were suitable criteria of resp
onse. However, using bone bending moment as the criterion of response,
the availability of P in soya-bean meal was 0.81, which was considera
bly higher than the estimate with pigs. Overall the results indicated
that the estimates of the availability of P in feeds for pigs were dep
endent on the criteria used to assess availability and that the value
for rats led to an overestimate of the value for pigs.