The relationship between college students' goal orientations and teach
ers' subjective ratings of students was examined. Mastery (concern wit
h improving competence) and performance (concern with proving competen
ce to others) goals were distinguished according to Dweck and Leggett'
s (1988) theory. The authors predicted that the teachers would give mo
re favorable ratings to high-mastery students than to low-mastery stud
ents on 12 separate dimensions, including likelihood of being a succes
sful teacher. The relationship among goals, critical thinking skills,
and final course grades was also examined. The results showed a strong
relationship between mastery goals and teacher ratings, but no relati
onship among goals, grades, and an objective measure of critical think
ing. Implications for future research are discussed.