Recently, it has been argued that American Sign Language (ASL) should
be the first language of some deaf children and that English should be
taught as a second language. This article supports that argument on b
oth philosophical and empirical grounds. Philosophical support stems f
rom viewing deafness as a cultural difference rather than as a medical
disability. Empirical evidence dence demonstrates that (a) ASL is a n
atural language, (b) deaf children acquire ASL in a normal and predict
able manner when exposure occurs at an early age, and (c) deaf childre
n who acquire ASL at an early age may outperform other deaf children o
n all measures of academic achievement. Based on the empirical evidenc
e presented, implications for educational practice are provided.