The authors hypothesize that the effectiveness of external threats in
raising workers' effort is mediated by, among other labor market condi
tions, the presence or absence of a powerful union. In particular, the
y argue that because powerful unions reduce the potency of the externa
l threat of job loss (by making it more difficult for employers to dis
miss workers), the pace of work is less responsive to such a threat in
strongly unionized plants than in weakly unionized plants. The result
s of an analysis of data from the 1990 Workplace Industrial Relations
Survey in Britain support this hypothesis. The analysis also yields ev
idence that effort is increased where workers are rewarded individuall
y according to results, and where there are various communication chan
nels between workers and management.