Ch. Antoni, SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC-EFFECTS OF INTRODUCIN G SEMIAUTONOMOUS WORK GROUPS - A QUASI-EXPERIMENTAL LONGITUDINAL-STUDY, Zeitschrift fur Arbeits- und Organisationspsychologie, 41(3), 1997, pp. 131-142
Based on a literature review the results of a quasi-experimental study
of the social and economic effects of self-regulating work groups are
analyzed. The results show improved productivity and quality four yea
rs after the implementation of the first pilot group and two years aft
er the complete change of the production to self-regulating work group
s. Objective job analyses proved that there is more potential for self
development in the self-regulating work groups compared to the taylor
istic production. In contrast to these findings subjective job analyse
s did not find similar results. Although employees in the pilot groups
rated their jobs better than those in the tayloristic production, the
se differences disappeared after the complete production changed to se
lf-regulating work groups. However, the new groups did not show improv
ed ratings; rather, the pilot groups deteriorated. As possible alterna
tive explanations changing rating standards, the effects of a worsenin
g economic situation, and insufficient training of employees prior to
the implementation of the self-regulating work groups are discussed.