Dj. Campbell et al., MERIT PAY, PERFORMANCE-APPRAISAL, AND INDIVIDUAL MOTIVATION - AN ANALYSIS AND ALTERNATIVE, Human resource management, 37(2), 1998, pp. 131-146
Theories of motivation and common expectation argue that people who co
ntribute more to an undertaking should receive more from it. This expe
ctation has significantly influenced the design of compensation system
s. Merit pay reflects this influence. Nonetheless, in spite of intuiti
ve appeal and apparent theoretical support, merit pay rarely achieves
its objectives. This article reviews five common implementation issues
. It also argues that merit plans underemphasize important attribution
biases that affect performance judgements. These biases suggest that
such plans would still have limited effectiveness, even if implementat
ion problems were overcome. The article presents an alternative focuse
d on group accomplishment. (C) 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.