Ns. Raju et al., THE EFFECT OF CORRELATED ARTIFACTS AND TRUE VALIDITY ON THE ACCURACY OF PARAMETER-ESTIMATION IN VALIDITY GENERALIZATION, Personnel psychology, 51(2), 1998, pp. 453-465
The effect of non-zero intercorrelations among the three artifacts (cr
iterion reliability, predictor reliability, and range restriction on t
he predictor) and true validity on the accuracy of estimation in two v
alidity generalization models (Model 1 and Model 2) was investigated.
Only the Taylor Series Approximation 1 (TSA1) procedure from Model 1 a
nd the procedure with complete sample-based artifact data from Model 2
were included in this study. Six intercorrelation conditions (zero, l
ow positive, medium positive, low negative, low negative and positive,
and medium negative and positive) and two distributions of artifacts
were used in this investigation. The two major conclusions from this s
tudy are: (a) Both models yielded reasonably accurate estimates of the
mean of true validities (M rho) and (b) only Model 2 produced accurat
e estimates of the variance of true validities (V rho) The need for ad
ditional research for accurately estimating V rho when the three artif
acts and true validity are correlated is recommended.