Mr. Law et Jk. Morris, BY HOW MUCH DOES FRUIT AND VEGETABLE CONSUMPTION REDUCE THE RISK OF ISCHEMIC-HEART-DISEASE, European journal of clinical nutrition, 52(8), 1998, pp. 549-556
Objective: To quantify the relationship between fruit and vegetable co
nsumption and the incidence of ischaemic heart disease. Design: A meta
-analysis of cohort studies of the relationship between ischaemic hear
t disease and markers of fruit and vegetable consumption, namely dieta
ry intake of fruit, vegetables, carotenoids, vitamin C, fruit fibre an
d vegetable fibre, and serum concentration of carotenoids and vitamin
C, adjusted for other risk factors. Main outcome measures: Risk of isc
haemic heart disease at the 90th centile of consumption relative to th
at at the 10th, equivalent to about a four-fold difference in fruit co
nsumption and a doubling of vegetable consumption. Results: The associ
ation with ischaemic heart disease was of similar magnitude for all si
x dietary markers of fruit and vegetable consumption. The median of th
e six estimates was that risk was 15% (range 12-19%) lower at the 90th
centile of consumption than at the 10th. The estimates were generally
adjusted for the possible confounding effect of other heart disease r
isk factors. The serum studies of vitamin C were consistent with this;
those of carotenoids suggested a larger difference (43%) bur were not
adjusted for the important confounding effect of smoking. The substan
ces in fruit and vegetables responsible for the protective effect on h
eart disease are uncertain but the effect is commensurate with the est
imated protective effects of the potassium and folate in fruit and veg
etables. Beta-carotene or vitamin E are not likely to be important bec
ause randomised trials of these vitamins in large doses have shown no
reduction in heart disease mortality. Conclusions: The risk of ischaem
ic heart disease is about 15% lower at the 90th than the 10th centile
of fruit and vegetable consumption.