Dl. Hopkins et Nm. Fogarty, DIVERSE LAMB GENOTYPES - 1 - YIELD OF SALEABLE CUTS AND MEAT IN THE CARCASS AND THE PREDICTION OF YIELD, Meat science, 49(4), 1998, pp. 459-475
Carcass measurements and composition data were obtained for 591 lambs
representing two sexes (307 cryptorchid males, 284 ewes). The lambs we
re sired by a selection of Texel (T), Poll Dorset (PD), Border Leicest
er (BL) and Merino (M) rams, crossed with Border Leicester x Merino (B
LM) and Merino (M) ewes giving 6 genotypes (Tx BLM, PD x BLM, T x M, P
D x M, BL x M, M x M). M x M carcasses were significantly (p<0.05) lea
ner than all other genotypes as measured by GR at a common weight, exc
ept for ewe carcasses where they were not significantly leaner than T
x M carcasses. There was no difference in GR between Texel and Poll Do
rset sired carcasses. The BL x M and PD x BLM carcasses were the fatte
st at the 5th rib. M x M lambs produced the lightest carcasses in each
sex. Genotype differences were found for conformation using the EUROP
scoring system. M x M lambs had a greater proportion (p<0.001) of poo
rer scores particularly compared to PD x BLM and Tx BLM carcasses. Ana
lysis of Texel and Poll Dorset sired carcasses showed that the Texel c
ross had a better conformation than Poll Dorset cross amongst both sex
es. BLM dams produced carcasses with a superior conformation compared
to Merino dams (p < 0.001) in both sexes. BL x M carcasses had a signi
ficantly (p < 0.05) smaller M. longissimus thoracis et lumborum area (
LL area) than other genotypes, except for M x M ewe carcasses. Texel s
ired ewe carcasses had a larger LL area (p < 0.05) than those sired by
Poll Dorsets, but there was no significant difference for the heavier
cryptorchid carcasses. Saleable meat yield for the BL x M carcasses O
f both sexes was significantly less (p < 0.001) than all other genotyp
es. M x M carcasses of both sexes produced similar amounts of saleable
product to second cross carcasses with the T x M carcasses being supe
rior, resulting in a significant sire breed effect. Texel sired carcas
ses produced more product than Poll Dorset carcasses. Year had a signi
ficant (p < 0.005) effect on all carcass measures and saleable meat yi
eld. Genotype had a significant (p <0.05) effect on the proportion of
each cut except for the neck from cryptorchids and neck fillet from ew
es. Texel sired genotypes had significantly ( p < 0.05) heavier weight
s for the hindleg and forequarter cuts than those sired by Poll Dorset
s. For the BL x M and M x M genotypes, some of the hindleg cuts, such
as the topside and silverside weighed less than other genotypes. The b
oneless loins from the Poll Dorset genotypes were the heaviest, result
ing in a significant (p < 0.05) sire breed effect, with all other geno
types being similar. Models were developed to estimate the yield of cu
ts and saleable meat using hot carcass weight, GR and other variables.
The amount of variation in yield explained by hot carcass weight and
GR ranged from r(2) = 0.06 to 0.23. Inclusion of LL area increased the
r(2) values up to 0.39. Inclusion of both genotype and year significa
ntly (p < 0.05) improved the prediction of yield, with year contributi
ng the most. The addition of sex had no effect on the prediction of yi
eld. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.