Jk. Klingner et al., COLLABORATIVE STRATEGIC READING DURING SOCIAL-STUDIES IN HETEROGENEOUS 4TH-GRADE CLASSROOMS, The Elementary school journal, 99(1), 1998, pp. 3-22
In this study we investigated the effectiveness of a cooperative learn
ing approach designed to foster strategic reading in 3 heterogeneous,
culturally and linguistically diverse, general education classrooms in
1 school. Fourth graders in an 11-day experimental condition (N = 85)
were taught by the researchers to apply reading comprehension strateg
ies (''preview,'' ''click and clunk,'' ''get the gist,'' and ''wrap up
'') while reading social studies text in small student-led groups. Con
trol condition students (N = 56) in 2 classes did not learn comprehens
ion strategies but received researcher-led instruction in the same con
tent. Outcome measures (a standardized reading test, social studies un
it test, audiotapes of group work) indicated that students in the expe
rimental condition made greater gains in reading comprehension, F(1,13
8) = 10.68, p =.001, and equal gains in content knowledge. Discourse a
nalyses of peer talk during cooperative group sessions indicated that
65% of discourse was academic in nature and content related, 25% was p
rocedural, 8% was feedback, and 2% was unrelated to the task. Students
implemented the clarification (click and clunk) and main idea (get th
e gist) strategies the most consistently and effectively.