Rb. Mcneal, HIGH-SCHOOL EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITIES - CLOSED STRUCTURES AND STRATIFYING PATTERNS OF PARTICIPATION, The Journal of educational research, 91(3), 1998, pp. 183-191
Much existing research documents the benefits gained by students when
they participate in high school extracurricular activities (Camp, 1990
; Eidsmore, 1964; Haensly, Lupkowski, & Edlind, 1986; Holland & Andre,
1987; McNeal, 1995; Yarworth & Gauthier, 1978). However, we know litt
le about the patterns of participation (i.e., who is more likely to pa
rticipate in which activities?), A finding in this research was that e
xtracurricular activities are not equitably participated in by various
subgroups of the high school population. To some degree, members of v
arious racial and ethnic minority groups have greater likelihood(s) of
participating in all types of extracurricular activities studied (ath
letics, cheerleading, fine arts, academic organizations, newspaper/yea
rbook, student government/service organizations, and vocational activi
ties), Girls have an increased likelihood of participating in all the
activities except athletics, which are dominated by boys, Finally, evi
dence also supports the hypothesis that the high school extracurriculu
m is one arena in which students of higher socioeconomic standing and
greater academic ability have a distinct advantage, Given the differen
tial rates of participation, and specifically the increased rates by v
arious minorities, restricting access to or eliminating specific activ
ities may make student access, and the resulting benefits from partici
pation (e.g., network, prestige, cultural capital), less equitably dis
tributed among the student population.