Sr. Forness et al., SPECIAL-EDUCATION IDENTIFICATION OF HEAD-START CHILDREN WITH EMOTIONAL AND BEHAVIORAL-DISORDERS IN 2ND-GRADE, Journal of emotional and behavioral disorders, 6(4), 1998, pp. 194-204
Underidentification of emotional and behavioral disorders (EBD) appear
s to be a particular problem for children from low-income families. In
the current study, two cohorts of 3,694 second-grade children across
30 sites were screened for EBD as part of a larger study on Head Start
transition. At-risk status for EBD was determined by developing two s
ets of research diagnostic criteria. One set reflected the current fed
erally mandated school definition of emotional disturbance (ED), which
requires that ED symptoms in school be accompanied by functional impa
irment in academic or social skills. The second set reflected a propos
ed alternative definition that would require both school and parent in
volvement in determining the presence of symptoms. Children were asses
sed using clinical cutoff points on behavior rating; from teachers and
parents, along with a determination of functional impairment in socia
l skills or academic achievement. Actual school identification of chil
dren was done through a school archival records search in the spring o
f the children's second-grade year. Identification rates for the crite
ria sets were 16.9% far the current school definition and 6.2% far the
alternative definition. Most participants identified by either criter
ia set were identified by the schools as belonging in categories other
than emotional disturbance. Findings are discussed in relation to mis
identification of children with EBD and possible gender or ethnic bias
es.