Sp. Miller, KEEPING THE PROMISE - THE ADA AND EMPLOYMENT DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF PSYCHIATRIC DISABILITY, California law review, 85(3), 1997, pp. 701-747
The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and its predecessor, the Reh
abilitation Act of 1973, have done a great deal to address the problem
of discrimination against individuals with physical disabilities. The
ADA has not been as successful, however, in curtailing discrimination
based on psychiatric disabilities. In interpreting the ADA in the con
text of psychiatric disabilities, courts have often turned for guidanc
e to precedents established under the Rehabilitation Act. This Comment
argues that much Rehabilitation Act precedent is simply inappropriate
for interpreting the ADA, for two reasons. First, the ADA differs fro
m the Rehabilitation Act in ways that should offer greater protection
to persons with psychiatric disabilities. Second, many Rehabilitation
Act precedents are infused with the very stereotypes and prejudices ag
ainst individuals with psychiatric disabilities that the ADA ought to
avoid. Concentrating on the ADA's employment discrimination provisions
, the author examines several of the central questions courts face in
cases involving psychiatric disabilities. She suggests ways in which c
ourts interpreting the ADA ought to address these questions, casting a
side when necessary the outdated guidance offered by Rehabilitation Ac
t cases.